|
UNIFORMED SERVICES EMPLOYMENT AND
REEMPLOYMENT RIGHTS ACT
Sample Employer Policy
The Uniformed Services Employment and
Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA) is codified in title 38,
United States Code, sections 4301-4333 (38 U.S.C. 4301-4333).
You can find the complete text of USERRA and other valuable
information on the website of the National Committee for
Employer Support of the Guard and Reserve (ESGR). Go to
www.esgr.com and click on
"The Law/USERRA."
In response to numerous requests, ESGR has prepared this
sample employer policy on compliance with USERRA. This is a
sample policy only and does not replace the advice of legal
counsel. Because of the differences in specific state laws and
individual employment situations, policies may vary greatly
from this sample policy. You should refer this sample policy
to your own legal counsel, as ESGR does not purport to give
legal advice.
This sample policy summarizes USERRA, and is intended to
incorporate all the minimum requirements of the law. For
definitive information see the text of the statute itself.
USERRA does not supersede any employer policy, collective
bargaining agreement, or state law that provides greater or
additional rights to those who leave civilian employment for
service in the uniformed services. See 38 U.S.C. 4302(a). In
other words, your company is certainly permitted and indeed
encouraged to do more than the law requires. Indeed, some
state statutes and local ordinances may require more than
Federal law. In any case, ESGR recognizes and honors those
employers who go "above and beyond the call of duty" in
accommodating military service by employees.
Sample Employer
Policy Part II
Under the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment
Rights Act (USERRA), our company is required to grant an
unpaid military leave of absence to any employee who requests
such leave in order to perform service in the uniformed
services. It is the policy of our company to comply with
USERRA and all other state, federal , and local laws. In case
of any conflicts between this policy and federal, state, or
local laws, such applicable laws shall control, subject to
conflict of laws principles.
The uniformed services are the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air
Force, Coast Guard, and the commissioned corps of the Public
Health Service. This includes the Reserve components of these
services and the Army National Guard and Air National Guard.
Under another Federal law, enacted in 2002, Congress has
extended reemployment rights under USERRA to persons who serve
as Intermittent Disaster Response Appointees (IDRAs).
IDRAs are temporary, intermittent employees of the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services. They respond, often
on very short notice, to emergencies involving infectious
diseases or weapons of mass destruction, and they also engage
in training for such dire contingencies. They are protected by
USERRA both for actual emergencies and for training.
USERRA broadly defines the term "service in the uniformed
services,"
as follows:
The term "service in the uniformed services" means the
performance ofduty on a voluntary or involuntary basis
in a uniformed service under competent authority and includes
active duty, active duty for training, initial active duty for
training, inactive duty training, full-time National Guard
duty, a period for which a person is absent from a position of
employment for the purpose of an examination to determine the
fitness of the person to perform any such duty, and a period
for which a person is absent from a
position of employment for the purpose of performing funeral
honors duty as authorized by section 12503 of title 10 or
section 115 of title 32
38 U.S.C. 4303(13)(emphasis supplied).
An employee of this company who leaves his or her job for
voluntary or involuntary service in the uniformed services
will, upon giving us notice, be granted an unpaid military
leave of absence. Some of our employees will perform inactive
duty training in the National Guard or Reserve. Such inactive
duty training is normally but not always performed on
weekends. Those National Guard and Reserve members will also
perform annual training and/or specialized training in their
Reserve components. National Guard and Reserve service is no
longer limited to "one weekend per month and two weeks per
year." Many National Guard and Reserve members now perform
training that is much more frequent and lengthy.
With two exceptions, our company is not required to pay an
employee who is away from work performing service in the
uniformed services. The first exception is under section
4316(d) of USERRA, 38 U.S.C. 4316(d). An employee who is away
from work performing service in the uniformed services is
entitled (not required) to use and be paid for any vacation
that the employee has accrued and not used prior to the period
of service. Normally, the company is not required to accede to
an employee's request to take vacation at a particular time,
but in this case we do not have that option. If the employee
has vacation to use and requests to use that vacation during a
period of service, our company is required to honor that
request. We are not required to advance vacation days to an
employee under these circumstances, but the employee is
entitled to use any vacation days that he or she has already
accrued.
The choice to use vacation during service rests entirely with
the employee. It would be unlawful for the company to require
the employee to use accrued vacation days in this way. Some
employees will want to use their vacation days during service,
in order to maximize earnings at a time of reduced income,
after mobilization. Other employees will want to conserve
their vacation days, in order to take vacation after returning
from service.
The other exception relates to managerial and executive
employees who are exempt from overtime rules under the Fair
Labor Standards Act (FLSA). These employees work on a salaried
rather than an hourly rate. If such an employee works part of
the week here at the company but misses another part of the
week while performing uniformed service, we are not permitted
to dock the employee for the hours not worked. We are
permitted to consider what the employee earns from the
military, and to pay the difference. If the employee is away
from work for the entire week, we are not required to pay
anything for that week. This is an FLSA requirement, not a
USERRA requirement.
USERRA applies to employees in probationary, seasonal, or
"temporary" positions. There is no requirement that the
employee have been employed for this company for any minimum
period before the absence for uniformed service.
USERRA is not limited to the National Guard and Reserve. An
employee who leaves employment with this company for service
in the regular military also can have rights under USERRA. The
law also protects an employee who takes a day or two off from
work for the purpose of an examination to determine fitness to
join any branch of the service. After completion of such an
examination, regardless of the outcome, the employee is
entitled to reemployment under USERRA.
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
An employee who leaves employment at
this company for service in the uniformed services will be
entitled to reemployment, provided he or she meets the USERRA
eligibility criteria:
a. The employee (or an appropriate officer of the
uniformed service) must have
given us prior oral or written notice of the impending service.
b. The employee's cumulative period or periods of
service, relating to this company,
shall not have exceeded five years.
c. The employee must have completed the period of
service without having received
a punitive or other than honorable discharge or having been
dismissed or
dropped from the rolls of the uniformed service.
d. The employee must have made a timely application for
reemployment or have
been timely in reporting back to work.
PRIOR NOTICE
We would prefer that the notice be in
writing, but oral notice is sufficient under the statute. We
want employees to give us as much advance notice as possible,
but we realize that circumstances arise where the employee
does not receive notice from the service until the last
minute. No specific amount of advance notice is required, but
the notice must be given before leaving the civilian job.
Advance notice is not required in those rare cases where
advance notice is precluded by military necessity or otherwise
impossible or unreasonable.
The specific wording of the employee's notice is of no
consequence, so long as the employee conveys the information
that he or she is leaving the job for the purpose of service.
The use of a word like "resign" does not defeat the employee's
right to reemployment, so long as the employee has informed us
that military service is the reason for the resignation.
Our company recognizes that individuals serving in the
National Guard and Reserve need time off from work sufficient
to enable them to travel to the place of training and have a
night of rest, before starting the training, so that they can
perform the training in a safe and effective manner. We will
approve requests to be away from work on Friday, and
particularly Friday evening, prior to inactive duty training
on Saturday.
FIVE YEAR LIMIT
The five-year limit is measured from the
date of commencement of the individual's employment
relationship with this company. Uniformed service performed
before the individual's hire date is irrelevant for purposes
of the individual's USERRA rights for this company. Reserve
and National Guard training and involuntary call-ups do not
count toward the individual's five-year limit. Some voluntary
service is also excluded in computing the five-year limit.
Please check with the personnel office before denying
reemployment on the basis of the five-year limit.
RELEASE FROM SERVICE
UNDER HONORABLE CONDITIONS
An individual does not have reemployment
rights with this company if he or she has received a punitive
(by court martial) or other-than-honorable discharge or if he
or she has been "dropped from the rolls" of the uniformed
service. Please check with the personnel office before denying
reemployment on the basis of the characterization of the
individual's service.
TIMELY APPLICATION FOR
REEMPLOYMENT
Period of 1-30 Days of Service
After a period of less than 31 days of service, the employee
is required to report for work at the start of the first full
regularly scheduled work period on the first day after the
completion of the period of service, the time reasonably
required for safe transportation from the place of service to
the individual's residence, and a period of eight hours (for
rest). If reporting that next day is impossible or
unreasonable because of factors beyond the individual's
control (like an accident on the return trip), the individual
is required to report for work as soon as reasonably possible
thereafter.
Period of 31 Days of Service or More
If the period of service is greater than 30 days but less than
181 days, the individual is required to submit an application
for reemployment within 14 days. If the period of service is
181 days or more, the individual must submit an application
for reemployment within 90 days. No particular form is
required for the application for reemployment, and our company
will not try to deny reemployment based on quibbling with the
wording. If the individual communicates with us, within the 14
days or 90 days, and tells us that he or she is available to
return to work after service, we will offer reemployment to
the individual.
Effect of Tardiness in Reporting
Back to Work
If the individual misses the relevant
deadline by a day or two, he or she is entitled to
reemployment, but he or she is subject to our usual policy
regarding explanations or sanctions for absence from scheduled
work. For example, assume that the employee is returning from
a period of 179 days of service and has 14 days to submit the
application for reemployment. The employee submits the
application on day 15. She has the right to reemployment, but
she may be subject to a two-week suspension without pay for
one day of unexcused absence.
ENTITLEMENTS AFTER
RETURN FROM SERVICE
Prompt
Reinstatement
After a period of less than 31 days of service, the employee
is required to report for work on the next workday, as
explained above. The employee will be considered to be back on
the payroll as of the time he or she reports for work.
After a period of 31 days or more of service, the employee is
required to submit an application for reemployment. If the
employee submits a timely application and meets the other
eligibility criteria, we will act promptly on that
application. We will not make the returning service member
wait for a vacancy, and if training or retraining is needed we
will offer it to the employee "on the clock." We will offer
reemployment to the individual not later than the start of the
second two-week pay period after the pay period when the
individual submits the application for reemployment.
For example, assume that the individual submits the
application for reemployment on Tuesday, December 30, 2003.
The next pay period begins on January 5 and the second pay
period begins on January 19. The individual will be offered
the opportunity to report back to work and be back on the
payroll as of January 19, if not sooner.
Continuous Accumulation of Longevity For Seniority
Purposes
A person who returns to employment with our company after
service in the uniformed services, and who meets the
eligibility criteria under USERRA, is entitled to continuous
company longevity for the entire period of the
military-related absence. This includes the period between
leaving the job and the start of the service, the period of
service, the period (up to 90 days) during which the
individual waited to submit the application for reemployment,
and the period between the application for reemployment and
returning to work.
For example, assume that Connie Smith joined our company on
January 1, 2000. On November 1, 2002, she gave us notice of
impending service and actually left the job on November 20,
2002. The person served on active duty from December 1, 2002
to November 30, 2003, and she applied for reemployment on
January 15, 2004. Upon her return to work on January 29, 2004,
she is entitled to continuous company seniority since January
1, 2000.
Upon reemployment, Connie Smith is entitled to pay raises,
promotions, and other benefits that she would have received,
in accordance with seniority, at some time between November
2002 and January 2004. It is our company policy to give the
returning veteran the benefit of the doubt. We will accord Ms.
Smith (and all others similarly situated) the promotions, pay
raises, and benefits that she probably would have received if
she had been continuously employed.
Continuous Accumulation of Longevity For Pension
Purposes
Our company has two pension plans. The basic pension plan is a
defined benefit plan, whereby a retiring employee receives a
monthly benefit computed on a formula that includes years of
company service and average compensation for the highest three
years of company compensation. This defined benefit plan is
funded entirely by the company.
We also have a supplementary defined contribution plan, funded
jointly by the company and individual employees. An individual
employee is permitted to set aside up to 10% of his or her
company compensation, pre-tax, and the company will match up
to 5% of the company compensation. Each employee has a
separate account in this defined contribution plan.
A returning veteran who is reemployed by our company, and who
meets the USERRA eligibility criteria, is entitled to be
treated as if she had been continuously employed, for purposes
of the defined benefit plan. For example, consider the case of
Connie Smith, from the previous section. Assume that she works
continuously (except for military-related interruptions) for
our company until she retires on January 1, 2030. Her monthly
pension check under the defined benefit plan will be exactly
the same as what it would have been if she had not been away
from work from November 2002 to January 2004.
The returning veteran who meets the USERRA eligibility
criteria will be given the opportunity to make up missed
employee contributions to the defined contribution plan. Such
make-up contributions must be made within the period that
begins on the date of reemployment and extends for three times
the period of service, but not more than five years. All such
make-up payments shall be made on a pre-tax basis. The
employee will be given the opportunity to set aside up to 10%
of her imputed income, during the period of service, even if
she was not putting money in the defined contribution plan
before the period of service. When she makes those
contributions, after returning from service, the company will
match all contributions, up to 5% of her imputed income.
Employer and employee contributions to the defined
contribution plan account will be based on what she would have
earned from the company during the military-related absence.
What she earned from the military is irrelevant. The
determination will be based on the pre-service rate of
compensation, plus any pay raises or promotions that are based
on seniority or cost-of-living that the employee would have
received during the military-related absence.
Some employees of this company are compensated in such a way
that the amount that the employee would have earned during the
military-related absence is not readily determinable after the
fact. For example, John Jones works in our sales force, and
more than half of his compensation comes from commissions. It
is impossible to determine exactly how much he would have
earned in commissions, if his career at our company had not
been interrupted by service. In that situation, the amount
that Jones would have earned will be computed based on his
average rate of compensation during the last year of company
service before the military-related interruption. If he was
employed for less than one year, the computation will be based
on his average rate of compensation during his entire period
of employment at this company.
Status
If the employee's period of service was
less than 91 days, he or she is entitled, upon reemployment,
to the exact job that he or she would have attained if he or
she had been continuously employed. In most cases, that will
be the same as the pre-service job.
If the period of service was 91 days or more, our company has
the option to reemploy the returning veteran either in the
position that he/she would have attained or, alternatively, in
another position of like seniority, status, and rate of pay.
Offering the returning veteran reemployment in a position that
is not of like status is not a sufficient compliance with
USERRA.
Location (commuting area) is an aspect of status. Offering to
reemploy the veteran in a distant city is not a sufficient
compliance with USERRA, unless the evidence establishes that
the job itself was moved to that distant city during the
employee's military-related absence. Other aspects of status
include hours of work (Most employees prefer to work during
the day, not at night.), opportunity to earn commissions or to
be promoted, etc. If we offer the returning veteran
reemployment in an alternative job, we must ensure that the
alternative job is equivalent in all respects to the job that
he or she would have attained if continuously employed.
If we offer the returning veteran reemployment in an
alternative position, it must be a position for which the
employee is qualified. Putting an employee in a position for
which he or she is not qualified is a recipe for failure and
would not be a sufficient compliance with USERRA.
Training or Retraining
If an employee returns to work after a long period of military
service, he or she may find that many things have changed in
the interim. There will have been technological developments
and changes in ways of doing business. The returning veteran
is entitled to the training or retraining that he or she would
have received if continuously employed.
Special Protection Against Discharge, Except for Cause
The returning veteran who meets the USERRA eligibility
criteria may not be discharged, except for cause, within one
year after reemployment, if the veteran's period of service
was 181 days or more. If the period of service was 31-180
days, the period of special protection is 180 days. If the
employee is discharged during the special protection period,
our company has a heavy burden of proof, to show that the
employee was discharged for cause.
This special protection provision applies even if the employee
was in an at-will or probationary status before leaving for
service. The special protection provision is intended to
protect the veteran from a bad faith or pro forma
reinstatement. Please do not try to discharge a returning
veteran during the special protection period without first
checking with the personnel office.
Entitlements of Returning Disabled Veterans
Some of our employees who have been called to serve will
return with temporary or permanent physical limitations,
resulting from service-connected injuries or illnesses. In
such a situation, we are required to make reasonable
accommodations in equipment, scheduling, etc. in order to
enable the employee to perform the duties of his or her
escalated reinstatement position (the position that he or she
would have attained if continuously employed). Of course, some
disabilities cannot be accommodated. If the employee cannot be
reinstated in the escalated reinstatement position, he or she
is entitled to reinstatement in some other position, the
duties of which he or she can perform despite the limitations.
The employee is entitled to the position that comes as close
as possible (in terms of seniority, status, and pay) to the
position to which he or she would be entitled but for the
disability.
Reinstatement of Health Insurance Coverage
An employee returning from service, and who meets the USERRA
eligibility criteria, is entitled to immediate reinstatement
of our company health insurance coverage upon reemployment.
This applies to coverage for the employee and for family
members who would have been covered if the employee had been
continuously employed. This includes children born or adopted
during the employee's military-related absence from work.
There must be no waiting period, and no exclusion of
"pre-existing conditions" except for conditions that the U.S.
Department of Veterans Affairs has determined to be
service-connected.
ENTITLEMENTS DURING SERVICE
Furlough or
Leave of Absence Clause
An employee who is away from work performing service in the
uniformed services is entitled to non-seniority benefits,
during the military-related absence, if and to the extent that
our company offers such benefits to employees on some other
form of leave, like jury leave, educational leave, or
maternity/paternity leave. Since our company has more than one
form of non-military leave, the comparison must be to the most
generous form of leave that we provide, whether that leave be
paid or unpaid.
Continuation of Health Insurance Coverage During Service
An employee who notifies us that he or she will be away from
work performing service is entitled to elect continued health
insurance coverage, through our company, during the
military-related absence from work. If the period of service
(as called for in the individual's military orders) is for
less than 31 days, the company is permitted to charge only the
employee share of the cost of the coverage. If the period of
service is greater than 30 days, the company is permitted (but
not required) to charge up to 102% of the entire premium,
including the part that the employer normally pays in the case
of active employees. We are required to make this continuing
coverage available to the employee who is away from work for
service until the first of the following occurs:
1. The employee returns to work after service.
2. The employee allows the deadline for an application for
reemployment to pass
without having made such an application.
3. Eighteen (18) months have passed since the employee left
his or her civilian job for
service.
The right to reinstated coverage after service is not
contingent on continuing coverage
during service. Most of our employees who leave for service of
more than 30 days will not elect continued coverage during
service, because during their service they are entitled to use
the military health care system for themselves and their
families.
Protection Against Discrimination
Section 4311(a) of USERRA provides as follows:
A person who is a member of, applies to be a member of,
performs, has performed, applies to perform, or has an
obligation to perform service in a uniformed service shall not
be denied initial employment, reemployment, retention in
employment, promotion, or any benefit of employment by an
employer on the basis of that membership, application for
membership, performance of service, application for service,
or obligation.
It would be unlawful for our company to deny an individual
initial employment, or to deny an existing employee any
benefit, or to fire an employee, because of the person's
membership in a uniformed service, obligation to perform
future service, etc. It is our policy to obey this law. We
will not consider military status or service when making
hiring, promotion, or firing decisions.
|